It was the evening of my third wedding
anniversary when having dinner with my wife (and Arsenal season
ticket holder) Vicky that the news broke – Harry Redknapp had been
sacked by Spurs.
At first I was devastated. Harry had
been a real ‘constant’ for Spurs, signed and managed some great
players, overseen probably the best Spurs squad in 30 years and taken
us into the Champions League. Not to mention achieving a fourth
place, to which us fans were disappointed with.
This to me was a terrible idea, not to
mention the following decisions to allow coaching staff Joe Jordan,
Kevin Bond and Clive Allen to leave as well. Then I started to think
about how last season had gone – I was at the 5-0 win against
Newcastle which was the last great result before the season went
downhill.
I’ll cite the excellent
article
by the BBC’s Phil McNulty, where he laid out some of the failures
of the management in regard to the second half of the season. From my
view, the biggest failings are what our newly appointed manager Andre
Villas-Boas will have to correct, but one of the main
failings was the refusal to rotate or rest players, despite Luka
Modric looking visibly tired and too much reliance on Adebayor
regardless of his low scoring rate.
Firstly, I have remained positive yet
sceptical about AVB. I see him as a manager who has had a very good
grounding via Bobby Robson and Jose Mourinho and who has seen the way
management should be done. His success at Porto is pretty unknown,
mainly because Mourinho signed a lot of his Champions League-winning
team to Chelsea, and AVB arrived at Chelsea without such an impact as
‘the special one’.
His time at Chelsea was unfortunate; he
was faced with an old guard that even the most experienced manager
would have struggled to reason with. Yes his tactics were a little
questionable, his direction is unorthodox and his high defensive line
was the cause of some goals conceded.
The fact is that AVB was not given
enough time at Chelsea because the fans, players and owner expected
results and trophies; at Spurs I doubt he will face such a wall of
demand. He will be expected to deliver results; otherwise he would
not have been entrusted with such a heavy task.
However Spurs are not expecting to win
the league, we expect a top six finish and the return of Champions
League football would be a delight, but I expect that this demand
will allow AVB to be given time to instil his tactics and signings
into the squad and succeed over a longer period.
There were some Spurs fans comparing
him to Juande Ramos, I don’t see that – I see a young manager
with great ambition to succeed and with a task that can go one of two
ways. And there will be no room for failure.
That said, there does need to be some
changes and my suggestions are as follows:
1 – Sign some strikers: we looked
woefully short last season with loan signing Adebayor, emergency
signing Saha and squad player and perpetual bench-sitter Defoe our
only available options. We do have Van Der Vaart as an attacking
midfielder and this week’s signing of Gylfi
Sigurdsson this week will add competition for places and offer a
viable option for a 4-3-3 formation or 4-5-1 and to cover the right
wing.
2
– Reintroduce the reserve team: this was removed by Harry and led
to us loaning our players to lower division teams
rather than sit on our bench. A credible argument, but this led to us
being under-resourced with the likes of Caulker, Townsend, Carroll,
Nicholson, Smith and Kane being on loan elsewhere. The reintroduction
of the reserve team will allow these players to play regularly
against their peers and alongside established squad players to be
match fit and available to play immediately.
3 – Make decisions on squad players:
I was happy to see the club make the decision to let Krancjar and
Corluka go, mainly because you had to question what they brought to
the first 11. More decisions need to be made on the likes of Jenas,
Bentley, Gomes and Dos Santos (among others) and decide what they
offer to the team. If the answer is nothing and they can be sold at a
good price and replaced in the 25-man squad with a young player, then
that should be done.
4 – Treat the Europa League properly:
Ok so the Europa League is not the Champions League and I had no
argument with Harry’s decision to use it as a run-out for the
aforementioned young players, but with the right amount of ambition
we can win this tournament and what we want is trophies, and a
European one would be well received by all in AVB’s first season.
5 – Look at the long term for our
goalkeeping options: We have been blessed by the form and presence of
Friedel, Cudicini has been a viable replacement and the fans still
love Gomes, but we need to look at a 20 something arriving in the
next year who will be our next number one. A goalkeeper can take time
to settle (see Szczesny at Arsenal, Krul at Newcastle) so having
someone arrive sooner to work with these keepers can only be a
positive.
I therefore welcome AVB with an air of
suspicion – that it may take time to deliver the project and that
we may have to see the AVB era as a long-term option. I hope Daniel
Levy shares this view.
Many thanks to Dan Raywood a Spurs fan and friend, for his contribution and thoughts on the appointment of Andre Villas-Boas. Also check out his guest blog on Sol Campbell from earlier.